Showing posts with label VO Everybody's A Critic. Show all posts
Showing posts with label VO Everybody's A Critic. Show all posts

Monday, March 14, 2011

Review of Seattle's Don Quixote

The intrepid, globe-trotting D.S. Spring is back with another review from the road! Here's D.S.'s review of Seattle Opera's Don Quixote.

Too much sanity may be madness.
But the maddest of all see life as it is and not as it should be.

What a delightful endearing opera! Massenet and librettist, Henri Cain, based this opera, not on the Cervantes’ novel, Don Quixote, directly, but on a play by Jacques Le Lorrain. Le Lorrain had reduced the novel’s complexity, greatly simplified the main character and focused specifically on Don Quixote’s infatuation with Dulcinée. Madness, dreams, kindness and humanity were themes throughout and were beautifully portrayed in Massenet’s music.

Carlo Montanaro conducted the enchanting score. Stage Director, Linda Brovsky, kept the stage settings simple with over-sized books as sets and kept the action moving on stage. Flamenco dancers entertained us in almost all of the crowd scenes. Don Quichotte was a new role for Canadian bass-baritone, John Relyea, who sang and acted the part with much sensitivity. Argentinian bass-baritone, Eduardo Chama, was the quintessential Sancho Panza. Polish mezzo-soprano, Malgorzata Walewska, whom I last heard as Judith opposite John Relyea in Bluebeard’s Castle in Seattle in 2009, ably sang the role of Dulcinée. Don Quichotte’s horse, Rocinante, and Sancho Panza’s donkey, Dapple, were played by well-mannered live animals, which enhanced the charm of this production.

I left the opera house admiring Don Quichotte and wishing to see life, not so much as it is, but more as it should be.

D.S. Spring
March, 2011

Tuesday, February 8, 2011

World Premiere Of The Inventor

We love it when our globe-trotting, opera-loving friends visit other cities. That's because they love telling us all about the amazing operas they saw! D.S. Spring, a long-time patron and subscriber to Vancouver Opera loves to share her thoughts on the operas she's seen on her travels. Last year, she enjoyed operas in London, Paris, Santa Fe and Seattle.

D.S.'s shares with us her most recent trip to Calgary:



2 February 2011
The Inventor


Calgary Opera’s General Director, Bob McPhee, continues to be the most adventurous of opera company CEOs in Canada by staging one contemporary opera per year. This year it was not only a contemporary opera, but also a world premier with the production of The Inventor composed by Vancouver’s own Bramwell Tovey. Even though it is Tovey’s first opera, it is not the case for the librettist, John Murrell, who seems to be on a roll taking obscure Canadian characters (like Lillian Alling) and writing an opera about them.

The Inventor is about Sandy Keith, a black sheep in the Alexander Keith brewing family of Halifax, who reinvents himself several times after swindling associates of rather questionable money-making schemes. It has an all-Canadian cast along with Director, Kelly Robinson, who also directed Lillian Alling for Vancouver Opera, and Designer Bretta Gerecke, who created a stunning versatile set for this production.

Tovey’s music is quite sophisticated. It supported the singers well and strongly evoked the memories, feelings and desires of the characters on stage. The casting was perfect with baritone James Westman as Sandy Keith, tenor Roger Honeywell as Luther Smoot, bass Philllip Ens in several roles, soprano Laura Whalen as Mary, soprano Erin Wall as Cecelia and mezzo Judith Forst as Louise, Cecelia’s mother. With such good singers it was unfortunate that Tovey did not compose more melodic arias for them.

As a new opera being performed for the first time, the story of The Inventor hangs together quite well mainly because of the experienced librettist Murrell. However, to be a memorable opera and one that should be performed again, some minor revisions would be in order. A few arias especially in the first act should be rewritten to be more appealing to a contemporary audience and a couple of the characters, namely Cecelia and Louise, require a bit of tweaking in order for the denouement to be more effective. It is hoped that there will be a revision and a second chance to see this interesting opera.

~ D.S. Spring

Monday, November 22, 2010

A Trio of San Francisco Operas

We love it when our globe-trotting, opera-loving friends visit other cities. That's because they love telling us all about the amazing operas they saw! D.S. Spring, a long-time patron and subscriber to Vancouver Opera loves to share her thoughts on the operas she's seen on her travels. This year she's enjoyed operas in London, Paris, Santa Fe and Seattle.

D.S.'s shares with us her most recent trip to San Francisco Opera:

9 November 2010
Cyrano de Bergerac by Franco Alfano



Photo credit: Cory Weaver

Plácido Domingo can sing anything and I would love it! And, yes, he sang the lead in this opera and I loved it. He and Roberto Alagna have recently revived this rather obscure opera by Alfano, whose main claim to fame was completing Turandot after Puccini’s death. This opera is based on the life story of 17th century poet and freelancer, Cyrano de Bergerac with his grotesque nose and his secret love for Roxane, portrayed beautifully by Spanish soprano, Ainhoa Arteta. It is sprinkled with humour and fight scenes which add to a very entertaining performance. The realistic sets were originally designed for the production at the Téâtre du Châtelet in Paris in 2009. Alfano’s music, though not spectacular or memorable, was very supportive of the singers and actions on stage under the baton of conductor Patrick Fournillier.

Sometimes when I hear a revival of an obscure opera, I come away thinking that there is good reason to leave the opera in obscurity. Such was not the case with Alfano’s Cyrano De Bergerac. Even though the music was somewhat mundane, it is a sweet love story and the opera is well structured and entertaining. It is an opera worth staging and seeing again.


10 November 2010
The Makropulos Case by Leoš Janáček



Photo credit: Cory Weaver

Finnish soprano, Karita Mattila, was absolutely fabulous as Emilia Marty. Her versatility, charisma and stage-presence make this a perfect role for her. It was difficult to believe that this performance was her debut in this role. This was also the premier of a brand new production co-produced with Finnish National Opera, and with Production Designer, Frank Philipp Schlössmann, and Director, Olivier Tambosi. The sets, very effective for this opera, were quite stylized in black, white and shades of grey.

The lush music of Janáček in combination with the stylized stage-setting and the drama in the story made for a very memorable performance.


11 November 2010
Madama Butterfly by Giacomo Puccini



Photo credit: Cory Weaver

Well, two good performances out of three on an opera trip aren’t bad. Unfortunately, this performance was the one not worth seeing. What a mish-mash! Soprano, Daniella Dessi, was mis-cast as Butterfly. Her voice was a heavy Tosca voice, not a Butterfly voice. I am not sure what Director, Jose Maria Condemi, was thinking. Even though the revolving set was very realistic and Japanese-like, there was nothing Japanese about the acting on stage. Hand gestures were very Italian, which was okay for Pinkerton, sung by Stefano Secco, but not for Butterfly, Goro. Prince Yamadori or the Bonze. Butterfly showed no infatuation with Pinkerton in the first act making the end of the first act rather lame. Then Koken stage-hands, borrowed from Kabuki theater, moved props around, which seemed quite unnecessary and rather distracting throughout. The waiting scene with the humming chorus offstage in the second act, which normally is one of the most beautiful scenes in all of opera, was totally ruined by having the black-clad Koken figures revolve the stage a full 360 degrees.

Madama Butterfly, is an opera that I have always considered perfect in construction. Every note and every word is essential in the composition. But obviously, even a perfectly composed opera can be spoiled by a poor production, which is what happened here.


~ D.S. Spring

Friday, September 10, 2010

Reminiscences of Tristan & Isolde


Photo credit: Rosarii Lynch

The late Alan David Aberbach first introduced me to Richard Wagner’s Tristan & Isolde. In a Saturday morning SFU class, he shared with us excerpts from several different productions, one of which I vividly remember from Japan had Jessye Norman as Isolde on a stage with minimalist and somewhat oriental sets. Another had Birgit Nilsson in the role along with Jon Vickers as Tristan. He described the music as some of the most sensuous music ever written. But the sensuality of Tristan & Isolde is only one aspect of this complex opera. Aberbach made a lifelong study of Wagner and the philosophies that influenced his beliefs and his compositions. The concept of the human soul as having masculine and feminine parts and is only complete when fully united is probably portrayed more fully in T&I than in any other of Wagner’s operas.

I was intrigued with the explanations and examples presented by Aberbach, but was still not prepared for my very first live Tristan and Isolde performance in Seattle in August, 1998. The beauty of the voices of heldentenor, Ben Heppner, and dramatic soprano, Jane Eaglen, both at their absolute peak in 1998, added to the orchestral music to create one of the most memorable performances of any opera I have seen before or since. The sensuality and sheer physicality of this production under the direction of Francesca Zambello was incredible. As my husband and I drove home from Seattle early the next morning, we did not turn on the radio for fear that it would disturb the music and scenes in our heads. Some of those memories of that performance and music are still there.

After half a dozen Tristan & Isolde performances later, which included a Kupfer production emphasizing the homosexual tendencies of König Marke and Tristan, and a recent Bayreuth production that totally de-emphasized the human aspects of all of the characters except for Kurwenal, I was curious how Director Peter Kazaras would treat Tristan & Isolde this summer in Seattle. I was not disappointed. In contrast to Zambello’s 1998 sexually explicit production, the human soul was foremost in his presentation of Tristan & Isolde on stage. At no time during the first and second acts was there physical contact between any of the characters on stage. Tristan, sung by Clifton Forbis, and Isolde, sung by Annalena Persson, either acted in unison or as exact opposites. It was only in the third act when Isolde arrived at Kareol that she and Tristan joined hands as he died. Kazaras’ take-home message was obviously that the male and female aspects of the soul could not be completely unified except in death.

Seattle Opera’s orchestra, so familiar with Wagner’s music, played magnificently. Both Persson and Forbis certainly had the volume and stamina required for the taxing lead roles. They looked and acted their parts well. However, neither had the beauty in their voices that Eaglen and Heppner had in 1998. Forbis’ voice was, in fact, quite rough in his lower register. The supporting roles of Brangäne and Kurwenal were superbly sung by Margaret Jane Wray and Greer Grimsley, respectively.

So was Seattle’s 2010 Tristan & Isolde a memorable performance? The answer is no, certainly not like the one in 1998. However, was it worthwhile to see? Yes, it was – mainly because of Kazaras’ interpretation. I think this is one production that Alan Aberbach would have appreciated.


~ D.S. Spring

Monday, August 9, 2010

Lightning And Operas

Our globe-trotting, opera-loving correspondant is back! D.S. Spring, a long-time patron and subscriber to Vancouver Opera loves to share her thoughts on the operas she's seen on her travels. She regaled us with opera reviews from Bayreuth, San Francisco, Seattle,

A couple of weeks ago, D.S. Spring braved the crazy summer weather of Santa Fe to catch some cool operas.

Life is a Dream by Lewis Spratlan


Photo credit: Ken Howard

Santa Fe Opera continues in its tradition of expensively producing new and challenging operas with this premier. This opera, based on Pedro Calderón de la Barca’s play, La Vida es Sueńo, has had a long gestation. It was originally commissioned in 1978 for the New Haven Opera Theatre, which subsequently closed before this opera could be performed. Even though the original play was written in 1635, its theme of dream verses reality for life is universal and is as valid today as it was in the seventeenth century.

Spratlan’s “pan-tonal” music, led by conductor, Leonard Slatkin, was very expressive with respect to what was being sung and acted out on stage. The costumes were as if from a courtly fairy tale, but it was set on an esthetically-pleasing minimalist stage. Director, Kevin Newbury, brought the characters to life with their actions and interactions. The difficult role of Segismundo was ably sung by tenor, Roger Honeywell, who will be starring in Vancouver Opera’s premier of Lillian Alling. With the exception of the weak bass, John Cheek, as King Basilio, the other singers performed admirably.

Kudos to Santa Fe Opera for taking Life is a Dream from its dream-like state to reality.

Tales of Hoffmann by Jacques Offenbach


Photo credit: Ken Howard

This is a beautiful production of Hoffmann’s stories of his lovelife within a story all being told to a crowd in a classic German beer hall. It was directed by Christopher Alden with conductor Stephen Lord. Paul Groves, with his solid tenor voice, was an impressive Hoffmann. Soprano, Erin Wall, whom Vancouver audiences will hear again later this season in La Traviata, capably handled all of the roles of Hoffmann’s love interests. Understudy, Wayne Tigges, stepping in for Gidon Saks, who withdrew from the production, confidently sang the various villain roles while the theatrics of tenor, David Cangelosi, as the servant in each story, almost stole the show. Almost, because the star, who did steal the show, was mezzo-soprano, Kate Lindsey, who sang Hoffmann’s muse. She was absolutely perfect for this character and will reprise the role later this year at the Met. The versatile Lindsey recently starred as the pregnant Amelia in Seattle Opera’s recent premier by the same name and is certainly a rising artist to watch.

Albert Herring by Benjamin Britten


Photo credit: Ken Howard

This delightful comic opera of the antics of small town society is in stark contrast to Britten’s Peter Grimes. Unfortunately for some unknown reason Director, Paul Curran, felt he had to ham it up with slap-stick actions rather than letting the characters stay true to type and just be themselves. The stodginess of Lady Billows, her housekeeper and other citizens in the town compared to the easy-going Sid and Nancy, when played straight, is normally more than sufficient to bring out the humour of the story as we observe Albert Herring coming of age and discovering himself. The statement that Britten was trying to make about society in small towns by poking fun at it was totally lost in this production.

Tenor, Alec Shrader, sang Albert Herring satisfactorily, but without being impressive. The rich baritone of Canadian Joshua Hopkins as Sid and the already-mentioned fabulous mezzo of Kate Lindsey were the vocal highlights of this performance.

This year Mother Nature presented her own magnificent show and competed with what was happening on stage. Each night around this covered, but open-air, amphitheater there was intermittent loud heavy rain that competed, and in some cases drowned out, the singers on stage. The continual lightning strikes in the distance, especially during the performance of Tales of Hoffmann, were awe inspiring. Each evening I felt we had two good shows on simultaneously for the price of one.

~ D.S. Spring

Wednesday, June 2, 2010

Moby Dick And Amelia Make Me Anticipate The Arrival Of Lillian Alling

It has been my privilege to experience many world premiere operas. From Dead Man Walking to Dr. Atomic, Nicholas & Alexandra to Anna Karenina, Cold Sassy Tree to Cyrano, seeing new additions to the operatic canon has been something that I have relished over the past 15 years. While some have thrilled and others frustrated, I am always eager to experience something new. That is why I went on a recent journey to see two world premieres in a week.

Photo credit: Karen Almond

The first stop was to Big D to experience Dallas Opera’s Moby Dick composed by Jake Heggie. While I had not read the Melville classic, the opportunity to see the work and how the story would translate to the stage was most enticing. It promised to be a great evening of theatre. Thankfully, the novel was pared down to a manageable tale to tell - one that made sense and didn’t require an understanding of the entire book to appreciate. The physical production was quite impressive with an innovative set, amazing video projections and an effective wooden peg leg for Ben Heppner as Captain Ahab. In fact, it was most often for something technical in the production that the audience erupted with appreciation. That was quite telling about today’s audiences and through which points they most readily connect with live performances.

The artists delivered some spectacular performances that evening. Ben Heppner was an amazing Ahab. His physical appearance along with vocal power made it clear that he could command this extensive crew of men with a combination of respect and intimidation. Among my other favourites were Stephen Costello as Greenhorn and Morgan Smith as Starbuck. Robert Orth was wonderful as Stubb. After 3 different productions, it was nice to see him in a role other than Nixon. Given what a transformation this role was to my mental perception of him only made me more impressed with his ability to embody the former president of the U.S. It was one of Stubb’s arias that stuck in my head and had me humming as I left the theatre. As far as music was concerned, it was not the vocal lines that connected me to the tale as much as the rich orchestration. The score was beautiful and epic in feeling. The imagery and colours it evoked were rich. It’s great to know there were several co-producers meaning this work will make more appearances around North America.

Photo credit: Rozarii Lynch

The next stop was in Seattle for their conclusion to the season, Amelia by Daron Aric Hagen. The company had put out some wonderful material to familiarize audiences with the piece, but it still took until I read the synopsis to fully understand how complex a tale I was about to experience. The opera was not focused specifically on the well-known aviator but rather was a weaving of stories that took place in different eras. Some were presented simultaneously, and I found that interesting and intriguing. The technique for telling the story became more interesting to me than the story itself. The physical production was impressive. It was, in fact, what I most heard audiences talking about at the intermission. I was two for two on being impressed about how the companies had invested significant resources to develop captivating sets, and again it confirmed how much of the audience was accessing the piece.

As I looked at trying to connect with the work, I found that I was really drawn to some impressive performances. William Burden, Nathan Gunn, Luretta Bybee and Jane Eaglen were as captivating as ever. Through the work, I was introduced to Kate Lindsey in the title role and Jennifer Zetlan as the female aviator evoked by the name. Again, incredible performances - especially by Ms. Lindsey whose acting chops were put to work with the complex story line. Musically, the work did not grab me in the same fashion as the week’s previous offering. As is often the case with newer operas, I left the theatre not offended by the melodies used to sing the dialogue, but not having a sense of repetition that would have allowed any of them to linger in my head much beyond when they were initially uttered. The orchestration was effective for what it needed to accomplish, but felt like it was as much about creating interludes for scene changes as it was for informing us about the tale that was unfolding onstage.

I realized through this that I tend to look at operas - particularly new ones - through five different areas. In doing so, I have found an ability to really identify and share the joy that I found in each evening with a new creation. The areas in which I focus are:

1. The story/libretto
2. The vocal line
3. The orchestration
4. The physical production
5. The performances

Illustration credit: Leonard Dente

Why am I so excited for the arrival of Lillian Alling? Looking at these five areas the answers would be:

1. The story is accessible and interesting. It is character driven and it unfolds in a manner that is consistent with many plays and films. Thus, audiences can enter it pretty rapidly and not spend too much time as an analytic observer. Plus, I have already experienced sympathy for the characters and teared up at sing-throughs in a church hall with only piano accompaniment. Imagine what will be possible with a full orchestra, sets and costumes.

2. From the musical workshops that we have done for this work, there are already some vocal lines that stick with me. I think that the composer is using a mix of sung dialogue and repetition to give audiences hearing it for the first time some musical handles to hold on to. That is something that I appreciate.

3. I haven’t heard any of this yet, but John Estacio’s other works seem lush and evocative. The answer to this will be revealed in the fall I guess.

4. Again, time will answer this one. However, the design renderings that I have seen seem to be an effective mix of the literal and those elements that allow us as audiences to use our imagination - creating in our minds the production that we each individually need and want to see.

5. We have seen many of these performers on the Vancouver Opera stage already, and they deliver. It has also been a joy to see some of them working on the evolution of their roles throughout the workshop process for the creation of the opera. There is already a depth to the characters they are portraying that comes through in their performances.

Like most audiences, I don’t expect to love everything equally. I am just always excited to experience something new that allows me to appreciate more fully what is possible with the art form. Sometimes that comes by experiencing something that was truly effective, and sometimes it comes from seeing something that didn’t quite work but reminded me of a prior experience that was successful. Thus, it solidifies my appreciation for the former. Having a chance to see two world premieres in short succession was a unique opportunity - especially when neither was lacking in resources to ensure a good quality product. It just goes to show that opera is a pretty powerful story-telling tool. When you have successfully assembled characters, with music and creative visionaries, one can cross vast seas, soar the skies or even scale mountains.

~ Jeff Sodowsky, Chief Development Officer